The Surprising Side of Roosters

by Beth

When our first flock was 16 weeks old, I thought I’d made a huge mistake intentionally raising a rooster. The nasty Yeti named Rooster Cogburn had just injured a couple pullets (baby hens) and had started pecking me, too. Hard.

Weeks before, he was a sweet lap chicken. Now Donna was missing the tip of her comb, and Miss Eula’s bell was rung so hard it apparently impacted her crop. Cogburn was dangerous.

His behavior was worst in the coop where the pullets couldn’t get away, so even as I fed Eula olive oil and massaged her neck (her crop went down in a couple hours, thank goodness), Chris was building us a separate coop, later dubbed, “Cogburn’s Cabin for Angry Birds.” We separated Cogburn into the cabin to plan our next move.

Back when planned this first flock, we had the farmers co-op order a male Brahma chick for us. Brahmas are labeled a “docile” breed, and roosters are supposed to protect the flock and keep the peace among the hens. Now ours was causing more chaos than he prevented. If he were going to be this aggressive, could we keep him? I dove into research to figure out what we were missing.

Why So Angry, Bird?

First of all, contrary to what we’d heard, Brahma boys aren’t necessarily more docile than other roosters. Secondly, experienced people often avoid adding roosters until their hens are old enough to stand up for themselves. Females mature more slowly than males, so a flock the same age will experience all kinds of disconnects during puberty that set the stage for a cockerel to turn into a bully. Older hens are less afraid to put roosters in check and teach them to be civil. Here’s a photo of Miss Eula standing up to young Stilton, an Easter Egger cockerel.

There’s a consensus that the easiest way to end up with an aggressive rooster is to hand-raise it around chickens its own age <–that’s exactly what I did. Doh.

The most helpful thing I learned is a rooster’s reason for being is to further his genes. This explains everything. He’ll do anything to protect his family.

Roosters can be silly and curious, but if they have a flock or an opportunity to grow one, biology can take over, and suddenly that rooster has zero sense of humor. Serious rooster face:


The slightest perceived interference can freak him out and cause static, like attacks on people and flockmates.

Humans interfere with rooster goals in more ways than we’ll ever know. We’re always stomping past the invisible boundaries roosters draw to protect their families. It’s easy for roosters to view even the kindest of humans as threats. Nature of the beast.


Removing our beast from the ladies’ coop worked wonders to calm everyone’s nerves. I worried if he’d be depressed if he were totally isolated, so we let him forage with the flock during the day. That worked, too. The pullets easily eluded Cogburn in the yard when he got beaky. Chicken-on-chicken injuries ceased immediately, and peace began to come over the flock again.

The real change happened 3 weeks later when some of the pullets started laying eggs. The layers were suddenly actively seeking Cogburn’s company, foraging and dustbathing with him instead of giving him wide berth. Cogburn responded by taking on the role he was born to play: protector and leader. Our rooster regret turned to fascination.


Misunderstood, Magical Male Chickens

Rooster stories are usually about 4 a.m. crowing or being attacked on the head as a child. Roosters are bossy, touchy, feathered bulls. It’s not surprising most of us don’t realize how hard they work.

Some days, I lift Cogburn up, and he’s so light I separate him from the pullets so he’ll eat, because he won’t eat in front of the flock. He has the weight of the flock on his shoulders even though he’s a growing chicken like everybirdy else. Both of our cockerels, including the little Easter Egger Stilton, have been willing to put themselves in harm’s way to round up their flockmates when there’s a threat like a low-flying hawk. Cogburn regularly hustles the pullets under cover and bakaws to alert us that something scary is approaching, like when a daytime raccoon came out of woods to case the the chicken yard.

Protection is one of the biggest reasons we thought a rooster was a good idea. We’re learning there are plenty of lesser-known behaviors that make roosters amazing.


I’d heard about this before owning a rooster, but it’s amazing to watch in person. Roosters comb the yard all day for treats. When they find something good like a bug, they pick up and drop it over and over while chook-chook-chooking to call the hens.

Cogburn will pick up and drop even his most favorite treats, saying, “Chook, chook, chook” until a hen comes running to see what he has. The louder the “chooks,” the better the treat.


In the above photo, you can see how badly he wants the sweet corn. Instead, he tossed the cob to the pullets and waited until they were finished to peck at the last kernels for himself. Researchers say this makes him more attractive and ensures his flock has the nutrients to make strong successors.

I love finding creative ways to sneak him treats to share to make his hens happy. Happy hens = happy rooster = happy chicken tender (that’s me).

Nest Selection

I had no idea all the ways roosters assist hens when it comes to laying, but it makes sense. Hens who feel calm and secure can lay more robust eggs.

When a beginner layer is ready to lay an egg, she might wander around for hours figuring out where to do that. She’ll settle into a nesting box, rearrange the wood chips and turn in circles to get comfy, only to hop up, go for a drink of water, then go to another nesting box and do the same thing.

What’s amazing is Cogburn will be right there with her. Here he is auditioning nests. Eula’s off camera, watching him closely. It’s like they’re shopping for furniture.

He makes a “chook chook chook” similar to when he has treats, calling the pullet over to see if the nest is cool. Honestly, the girls will act interested but rarely choose the nests he likes. You kind of wonder if they’re still mad at him for his bad behavior back when they were 16 weeks old.

Guarding the Laying Hen

If you enter the chicken yard when someone is laying an egg, it’s best not to turn your back on Cogburn, as you may receive a hard peck or kick. He keeps close watch on the coop.

Here’s a video from Peep’s first week laying, before she decided to try the nesting boxes. Cogburn was right outside, but when he realized how close I was, he came in to give me the rooster eye.

I appreciate the protection he’s offering them, so when someone’s laying, I stay out of the yard or try to be inconspicuous. He won’t chase me off, but he’s touchier when there’s a lady “setting.”


Making the Egg Call

Contrary to popular belief, it’s often Cogburn, not the hens, who sounds the BAKAWWW when an egg is laid. This was especially true with the first eggs. He stalked around the coop bakawing and crowing while the pullet wandered out to forage with the flock.

Cogburn usually bakaws to repel hawks, raccoons, butterflies, and airplanes, so we thought something was wrong the first time he was bakawing in the coop. When Chris and I peered in, Peep was just standing up to regard a perfect little egg. Isn’t it the prettiest?


The pullets have been mostly silent when they lay. There’s a post on that hypothesizes that a hen’s egg song is actually a call for a rooster to escort her back to the safety of the flock. Since Cogburn’s never far away, maybe our hens don’t find it necessary to call him over.

Time Heals All (October 2020 Update)

Exactly 10 weeks after the first night Cogburn spent in his cabin, he toddled to the big coop at dusk and hopped on the roost with the rest of the flock. Unlike when he tried this a few weeks ago, this time, nobody freaked out. The flock had finally welcomed him back.

These days, they argue over who gets to snuggle up with him at night. They used to sleep evenly spaced on the roost, but here they are crowding Cogburn so much he’s been pushed against the wall and nearly off the roost. You can see the Brahmas on the left planning how to get closer. He loves it.


Cogburn is now far kinder to his chickens and a beloved steward of the flock. He’s still crabby to me, however. I’ve tried all kinds of methods for “gentling” roosters: carried him around, put him into submissive posture, emulated grooming, fed extra protein and electrolytes, flatly ignored his rooster kisses (pecks), avoided bright shoes, and much more. He’ll respond to a firm “no” and turn around mid-charge, but we have a ways to go. Evidently, he’ll continue to evolve until he’s 2 years old.

Truly, it’s become clear that the best balm is time. Time for these teenage chickens to mature and for us to learn how to read and work with them.

There’s no question it would’ve been easier to raise hens only, but we’d have missed out on an awesome part of chickens. We’re at the beginning of our poultry journey, but it’s already obvious society doesn’t see these birds the right way at all. We might all be vegetarians if we did.


  1. They do usually mellow out some as they get older. We’ve had “good” and “bad” roosters and some that were just downright mean. We raised them all the same, so why some turn out one way is beyond me. I do know a good rooster is worth it’s weight in gold–protects the flock but doesn’t see humans as a threat.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Love this!!!! Mine are 22 weeks now so can relate to this fully. My 2 roos came very close to becoming Sunday roast many times during puberty (vegans here so said for effect!). Now, I can’t take my eyes off them. They are the most caring and fascinating, beautiful souls. They look after my girls like proper 1920’s gentlemen!!!! Xxx

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank goodness for time! It made all the difference with the big guy. And yes, they’re mesmerizing! Thanks for taking the time to comment 🙂


  3. What an outstanding, insightful & encouraging article on roosters. It’s always refreshing to find information that highlights the positives of having a rooster in your flock. This piece not only does that in a thoughtful way but also tells the story of a rooster who began to develop problematic behavior. Instead of instantly dismissing the rooster as a bad, they do what we all should do & try to understand where the behavior comes from. Further, after acquiring a good base of knowledge regarding the rooster’s behavior, they made some modifications. They showed the positive results that can come from working with the rooster instead of against it. Did it solve every issue? No, however, it did allow them to keep the rooster. This is not to say that every rooster can or should be kept for a variety of reasons but too many times we fail to even try to understand & appreciate roosters for the truly dynamic creatures they are. Thank you for this wonderful perspective on roosters.


    1. Thank you for reading and taking the time to comment. Your kind words mean a lot. “Dynamic” is a great word for roosters. Chickens are surprisingly observant and trainable, I think much more so than their keepers. We’re still learning daily with Cogburn and are grateful for him.


Leave a Reply to lorelei Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s